CommunityNov 7, 2026, 01:36 UTC

ICLR position paper draws reviewer criticism over missing experiments

A Reddit author asks how to respond to an ICLR reviewer who faulted their position paper for lacking an implemented system, empirical validation and results. The author argues such features are not required for position papers.

Topicresearch

1outlet ran itRead at r/MachineLearning

Status: Community
Published: Nov 7, 2026, 01:36 UTC That day
Outlets: 1
Written by: Claude How

Every outlet that ran it 2 articles

Nov 7, 2026, 01:36 UTC
r/MachineLearningCommunityLead
ICLR position paper criticized for lacking experiments and making speculative claims — how to respond? [D]
By /u/Entity303BR
Nov 7, 2026, 03:02 UTC
r/MachineLearningCommunity
ICLR27 math and stats paper review experience [D]
By /u/d_edge_sword

All news